Ugrás a tartalomhoz Lépj a menübe
 


Ockham borotvája

2012.06.06

 

 

 

 

Az oldalt itt találod

https://mondogatjuk.wordpress.com/mondogatjuk/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

tumblr_l9xaz7qwhq1qawlupo1_5001.jpg

 

Ockham borotvája

Ez egy olyan filozófiai elv, amit nem is Ockham talált ki, és nem is kell hozzá igazi borotva. Akkor szoktuk használni, amikor két történés közül kell kiválasztanunk a leginkább lehetségest. Az elvet szinte minden olyan területen alkalmazzák, ahol ”dönteni kell” de nincs mi alapján. Ennél persze sokkal bonyolultabb a történet…

 

Ockham

guillermo-de-ockham.jpgWilliam Ockham 1300 körül élt, és a világmindenség nagy kérdéseire próbált logikus válaszokat találni. Nem keltett ez akkoriban nagyobb feltűnést a filozófusok között, inkább az okozhatott gondot, amikor teológiai kérdésekre is kivetette az általa alkalmazott elveket. Miután az egyházból kiközösítették, IV Lajostól kért menedéket, továbbiakban politikáról és teológiáról írt.

 

Az elv

Két fő elvet tulajdonítanak neki, az egyik a mindenhatóság elve, a másik a gazdaságossági elv, ez utóbbi lenne a borotvához kapcsolodó.

 

De miért borotva?

"Borotvával hasítsuk ketté a szükségtelen hipotéziseket!" Állítólag így fogalmazott Ockham, mikor a gazdaságossági elvet bizonygatta. Maga az elv már létezett, Ockham csak felhasználta azt, de annyiszor és olyan sok formában, hogy idővel az ő nevéhez kötődött. A borotva, lehetne olló, vagy radír, vagy bármi ami kivonja a létezésből a szükségtelen feltételezéseket.

 

Mert mi az a gazdaságossági elv?

ockham-s-razor.gifErről bezzeg olvashatunk oldalakon át, különböző tudományos, néha egészen elvont témakörökben, és számtalan példával magyarázva, ameddig a végén a megértésből eljuthatunk, a mégsem egészen érthető, sőt igencsak ellenmondásos, aztán nagyon zavaros és egészen érthetetlen állapotig is.

Ocham borotvája, a gazdaságossági elv, a szükségtelen többlet elve, a logikai borotva, a takarékosság elve, a tömörség elve elnevezéseivel is ugyan azt a tételt fogalmazza meg:  A sokaság szükségtelenül nem tételezendő! Tehát ha egy tény, két különböző, de logikus további tényezőkre vezethető vissza, akkor azt kell választanunk, amiben kevesebb plusz feltételezés szükséges a magyarázathoz. Aki nem hiszi, járjon utána:

http://mek.oszk.hu/05200/05243/05243.htm

http://hu.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam_borotv%C3%A1ja

http://www.szabadgondolkodo.hu/szkeptikus/szotar/occam.php

http://ertem.hu/occam-borotvaja/

http://forum.szkeptikus.hu/viewtopic.php?p=39881

 

http://www.agent.ai/main.php/www.../img/main.php?folderID=166&articleID=2149&ctag=&ii

 

Érdekességek

A jó tétel minden időben, és minden helyzetben alkalmazható, így olyan témakörökben is találkozhatunk vele, amiről a 14. században még nem sokat tudhattak az emberek.

http://www.csatolna.hu/hu/erdekes/CsA/erdekes2125.htm

 

William of Ockham

vagy más írásmóddal Occam (1285?-1349) egy angol ferencesrendi barát volt, a 14. századi skolasztikus teológia és filozófia jeles képviselője. Nevéhez fűződik a híres elv, amit Occam borotvájaként említenek és alkalmaznak még ma is a különféle tudományok művelői. Nevét utca és penzió őrzi Münchenben, ahol öregkorában élt. De viseli egy programnyelv is, amelyet sokprocesszoros rendszerek párhuzamos műveleteihez fejlesztettek ki.

Éles esze úgy vágott, mint a borotva, amikor kitalálta, hogy: Non sunt multiplicanda entia praeter necessitatem. Talán jobban érthető így: Frustra fit per plura quod potest fieri per pauciora. Neeem? Akkor próbáljuk egy újabb változatban: Pluralitas non est ponenda sine necessitate. Már világos, ugye? Ha most sem, sebaj - nézzük, kik és hogyan használják, értelmezik:

  • A filozófus. Ateista válaszok a hívők tipikus kérdéseire - Occam borotvája. Ne szaporítsd szükségtelenül az entitásokat. Tehát: ha valamit meg tudsz magyarázni egy bizonyos entitás létezésének feltételezése nélkül, akkor tedd azt. Mindig a legegyszerűbb megoldást kell választani.
  • A vegyész. Sejtelem és Ockham borotvája. Hiábavaló többhöz folyamodnunk, amikor kevesebbel is megtehetjük ugyanazt.
  • A csillagász. Hale személyes nyilatkozata az UFÓkról. Ha egy jelenségre több lehetséges magyarázat létezik, mindig a legegyszerűbbet kell választani, amely az összes megfigyelt tényről számot ad.
  • A fizikus. What is Occam's razor? Keep it simple, stupid. (Ne bonyolítsd el, te hülye! ford. CsA) Az egyszerűség elve egy heurisztika, egy ökölszabály, de sokan a fizika egy axiómájának tekintik. Nem az. Egész jól működik a filozófiában és a részecskefizikában, néha a kozmológiában vagy a pszichológiában is, ahol a dolgok várakozáson felül elbonyolódhatnak. De itt már talán egy Hamlet idézet többet ér, mint Occam borotvája: "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy." (Több dolgok vannak földön és égen, Horatio, mintsem bölcselmetek álmodni képes. ford. Arany J.)
  • Az informatikus. Hogyan működik a tudomány? A tudományos problémák megoldásánál az Occam borotvája nevű elvet használják. Az elv a konkurrens elméletek közül azt fogadja el, amely kevesebb előfeltételezést igényel.
  • A mesterséges intelligencia kutató. Occam - Eine planungsbasierte Informations-Beschaffungsmaschine A gépesített cselekvéstervezés folyamatában alkalmazzák az elvet, annak érdekében, hogy a különféle információs forrásokból adatgyűjtéssel a legegyszerűbb és legolcsóbban végrehajtható tervhez jussanak. Az internetes metakeresők programjainak alapjaiban ugyancsak felbukkan az Occam elv és a belőle kifejlesztett algoritmus.
  • Az Encyclopedia Britannica. Ockham's razor. Law of economy or Law of parsimony (a takarékosság vagy zsugoriság törvénye).

OK, már érthető. Szóval Occam borotvájával le lehet nyisszantani a gondolkodásból a fölösleget, a terjengősséget. Be is fejezem.

És ismét egy félrefordítás (Leiter Jakab után), az Ockham-féle borotva, ahol az elvek márkanevekké változnak: http://leiterjakab.blog.hu/2011/08/29/az_occam_fele_borotva

 

 

Volt ilyen címmel Dr House rész és Eurékában is használták az elvet, további előfordulásai (film, sorozat, műalkotás, formáció, stb.) kerestetnek!

Film: Kapcsolat (Contact) című sci-fi.
 

 

occam.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hozzászólások

Hozzászólás megtekintése

Hozzászólások megtekintése

Part 3 All In

(patab6900093, 2021.10.17 11:05)

I sheepishly replied "Hi"."What your name" she asked. "Sarah", I replied."That’s cool we have the same name." She continued talking and as I started to relax realizing that she didn’t recognize me I started to open up and talk back. After our nails were done Sarah Asked if I wanted to shop with her. I looked at Jenifer and she said, "go ahead sweetie". We were off and after visiting several stores we went into a teen store. After looking for a little while Sarah lit up saying oh this is so cute "you have to try this one on". It was a light pink dress that flared out at the...
https://patab6900093.weebly.com/

Can I Borrow Your Wife? 1

(pheasant4785689, 2021.10.17 07:42)

Her skirt rides up above her ass and I have full view of he perfect ass and dripping wet pussy. I raise my hand up and come down on her ass with a loud slap. It leaves a nice big red hand print on her. She cries out "Thank you sir"I repeat the slap on her ass a couple more times until her entire bottom is red. Amiee turns back around and kneels on the floor in front of me again with her back leaned up against the bed. I take a fast glance at the window and Tom is staring with utter amazment on his face. I move my cock close to Amiee's mouth and she opens up without a second thought...
https://pheasant4785689.weebly.com/

Best Clinic in City

(DannydaG, 2021.10.17 01:27)

I want to find good clinic in my city. What do you think about this -
<a href=https://chicago-ridge.age-management-clinic.com>Chicago Ridge Anti-Aging PRP, Testosterone, Peptides, Exsosome and HGH Therapy Clinic</a>?

Early AM

(DIMONBRZ7465828, 2021.10.17 01:03)

I lay heavily on her firm body, pressing my mouth aganist her lips. I press hard on the front of her silken body; I knew it would be only seconds before I feel a response from her pussy. In a short-time, Wendy was feeling the urge from within herself, she pushs her pelvis aganist me, trying to writhe her thighs aganist my thighs, trying to get pleasure by pushing her belly to and fro aganist me. Suddenly I roll off of her to one side, she sees my expression change. My face now has a leer. My hands start to caress between her thighs rubbing her pussy. My hot hands caressing her smooth naked...
https://dimonbrz7465828.wordpress.com/

Bound for Pleasure

(KnuckleDust155401, 2021.10.16 21:45)

She didn’t even realize that his mouth had left her nipple until its assault began on her other one. A fresh ripple rushed through her as this breast finally got the same attention its twin had been receiving. Then she felt it. Just a gentle touch at the base of her pussy. Just pressed there, touching both lips, but not moving. How she wanted it to move upward and into her pussy, but it didn’t. Slowly she began to rock forward hoping to push it into her. But as she moved it moved with her. As she began to rock forward again the lips on her nipple were replaced with biting teeth on the...
https://knuckledust155401.wordpress.com/

Im happy I now registered 707854298

(GabrielFug, 2021.10.16 18:51)

new healthy man viagra scam stronger than viagra <a href="http://viagracore.com/">buy viagra on liine</a> men's health top male enhancement sildenafil 50 mg tablet [url=http://viagracore.com/]where can i buy viagra over the counter without a prescription[/url]

MY DAUGHTE IS A CUM DUMPSTE 3

(testtest2137489, 2021.10.16 18:26)

She was wearing the classic schoolgirl outfit. From the toes up she wore knee high white socks, a black and red plaid skirt that draped over the stool, and a white tank top without a bra highlighting her clearly erect nipples and small breasts. She even polished the outfit off with pigtails and a ribbon. It was the sexiest outfit I had ever seen. It was obvious that she was intentionally dressed like a slut and the truth is… I absolutely fucking loved it. The problem is, there is no way Stacey was not going to notice as well. Trouble was brewing. Renee was sitting there eating a bowl of...
https://testtest2137489.wordpress.com/

Audrey Hepburn

(MutantFate85247, 2021.10.16 15:05)

Everyone was invited, among the pairs gliding along in gentle waltz you could occasionally detect a familiar face; there was Rita Hayworth, dancing with some lucky guy. Sophia Loren, with her partner. The long-legged Cyd Charisse moving with unmatched grace, except for Ginger Rogers and Fred Astaire, of course. Even Marilyn Monroe was there, getting a lot of attention with JFK. But it was me, who danced with the most adorable of them all...Audrey blinked her huge, brown doe-eyes and smiled. The gown she was wearing was the one from Sabrina; a tight corset and a big flowing skirt, all in...
https://telegra.ph/Audrey-Hepburn-10-14

Golden Ass

(ImaxMadder8784400, 2021.10.16 11:44)

Naturally she put her arm around his shoulder. She didn’t know what he was doing, but she thought he was going to take her to where all the commotion was occurring.Terry looked at Kevin’s face. Then, slowly, he sank to his knees, and gently lowered her into the water, fully clothed. Terry squealed and beat on Kevin’s chest. By that time Pam saw what Kevin had done, she was already at her sister's side, helping her stand up. Pam was furious but Kevin, Amy and Martin were laughing. Terry splashed Kevin. Pam said, "I’m gonna beat your ass, you motherfucker." "Lighten up, Pam," Terry said...
https://telegra.ph/Golden-Ass-10-14

очень интересно но чичего не понятно

(RobertRew, 2021.10.16 09:00)

Супер давно искал
_________________
[url=http://kk.sportslive4k.site/558.html]онлайн-вулканнан қалай ақша табуға болады[/url]

The Erotic Adventures of a Bride-To-Be - Part Two

(KcyZonary4903508, 2021.10.16 08:24)

Plus, you don’t seem the jealous, intimidated type.""Here, you can help," said Laura, and let Brenna undo a few of the buttons on her top. As Brenna looked at her, she laughed and gave her a big hug."See, fun!"Laura had on a plain white bra that seemed to de-emphasize her bosom. She stepped out of her jeans and was wearing plain white panties."Your undies are so much cuter," said Laura."Um, thanks," said Brenna.Ellen came up behind Brenna and Maria came behind Laura, and they unhooked their bras. Slowly they were pushed off of the girl’s shoulders.Katerina now stepped...
https://telegra.ph/The-Erotic-Adventures-of-a-Bride-To-Be---Part-Two-10-14

should never have said it (final)

(Bulwark5708186, 2021.10.16 07:47)

In the week after all was arranged for my new job in Savannah, I had seen a solicitor and had him draw up a separation agreement as a prelude to divorce, in the agreement I asked that our home should be sold as soon as possible with the proceeds split equally, everything else would be apportioned by ownership, I had no wish to embarrass Amanda by suing for divorce on the grounds of adultery I hoped we could divorce amicably after a 2 year separation.One evening I sat Amanda down and gave her the agreement and asked her to read and sign it, she sat silently and read it several times, when...
https://telegra.ph/should-never-have-said-it-final-10-14

should never have said it (final)

(Bulwark5708186, 2021.10.16 05:06)

In the week after all was arranged for my new job in Savannah, I had seen a solicitor and had him draw up a separation agreement as a prelude to divorce, in the agreement I asked that our home should be sold as soon as possible with the proceeds split equally, everything else would be apportioned by ownership, I had no wish to embarrass Amanda by suing for divorce on the grounds of adultery I hoped we could divorce amicably after a 2 year separation.One evening I sat Amanda down and gave her the agreement and asked her to read and sign it, she sat silently and read it several times, when...
https://telegra.ph/should-never-have-said-it-final-10-14

should never have said it (final)

(Bulwark5708186, 2021.10.16 02:28)

In the week after all was arranged for my new job in Savannah, I had seen a solicitor and had him draw up a separation agreement as a prelude to divorce, in the agreement I asked that our home should be sold as soon as possible with the proceeds split equally, everything else would be apportioned by ownership, I had no wish to embarrass Amanda by suing for divorce on the grounds of adultery I hoped we could divorce amicably after a 2 year separation.One evening I sat Amanda down and gave her the agreement and asked her to read and sign it, she sat silently and read it several times, when...
https://telegra.ph/should-never-have-said-it-final-10-14

should never have said it (final)

(Bulwark5708186, 2021.10.15 23:48)

In the week after all was arranged for my new job in Savannah, I had seen a solicitor and had him draw up a separation agreement as a prelude to divorce, in the agreement I asked that our home should be sold as soon as possible with the proceeds split equally, everything else would be apportioned by ownership, I had no wish to embarrass Amanda by suing for divorce on the grounds of adultery I hoped we could divorce amicably after a 2 year separation.One evening I sat Amanda down and gave her the agreement and asked her to read and sign it, she sat silently and read it several times, when...
https://telegra.ph/should-never-have-said-it-final-10-14

Just wanted to say Hi! 255694979

(MichaelDip, 2021.10.15 23:28)

new antidiabetic drugs liquid cialis blue bottle cvs viagra coupons <a href="http://cialismub.com/">cialis daily use</a> indaziflam mode of action viagra class action lawsuit [url=http://cialismub.com/]tadalafil cialis bestprice[/url]

should never have said it (final)

(Bulwark5708186, 2021.10.15 21:10)

In the week after all was arranged for my new job in Savannah, I had seen a solicitor and had him draw up a separation agreement as a prelude to divorce, in the agreement I asked that our home should be sold as soon as possible with the proceeds split equally, everything else would be apportioned by ownership, I had no wish to embarrass Amanda by suing for divorce on the grounds of adultery I hoped we could divorce amicably after a 2 year separation.One evening I sat Amanda down and gave her the agreement and asked her to read and sign it, she sat silently and read it several times, when...
https://telegra.ph/should-never-have-said-it-final-10-14

should never have said it (final)

(Bulwark5708186, 2021.10.15 18:31)

In the week after all was arranged for my new job in Savannah, I had seen a solicitor and had him draw up a separation agreement as a prelude to divorce, in the agreement I asked that our home should be sold as soon as possible with the proceeds split equally, everything else would be apportioned by ownership, I had no wish to embarrass Amanda by suing for divorce on the grounds of adultery I hoped we could divorce amicably after a 2 year separation.One evening I sat Amanda down and gave her the agreement and asked her to read and sign it, she sat silently and read it several times, when...
https://telegra.ph/should-never-have-said-it-final-10-14

should never have said it (final)

(Bulwark5708186, 2021.10.15 15:14)

In the week after all was arranged for my new job in Savannah, I had seen a solicitor and had him draw up a separation agreement as a prelude to divorce, in the agreement I asked that our home should be sold as soon as possible with the proceeds split equally, everything else would be apportioned by ownership, I had no wish to embarrass Amanda by suing for divorce on the grounds of adultery I hoped we could divorce amicably after a 2 year separation.One evening I sat Amanda down and gave her the agreement and asked her to read and sign it, she sat silently and read it several times, when...
https://telegra.ph/should-never-have-said-it-final-10-14

Check this clinic

(HGHClinicdaG, 2021.10.15 10:41)

I need your opinion about this clinic -
<a href=https://birdsboro.age-management-group.com>Birdsboro Anti-Aging PRP, Testosterone, Peptides, Exsosome and HGH Therapy Clinic</a>. What do you think?


« előző

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 | 61 | 62 | 63 | 64 | 65 | 66 | 67 | 68 | 69 | 70 | 71 | 72 | 73 | 74 | 75 | 76 | 77 | 78 | 79 | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | 89 | 90 | 91 | 92 | 93 | 94

Következő »