Ugrás a tartalomhoz Lépj a menübe
 


Ockham borotvája

2012.06.06

 

 

 

 

Az oldalt itt találod

https://mondogatjuk.wordpress.com/mondogatjuk/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

tumblr_l9xaz7qwhq1qawlupo1_5001.jpg

 

Ockham borotvája

Ez egy olyan filozófiai elv, amit nem is Ockham talált ki, és nem is kell hozzá igazi borotva. Akkor szoktuk használni, amikor két történés közül kell kiválasztanunk a leginkább lehetségest. Az elvet szinte minden olyan területen alkalmazzák, ahol ”dönteni kell” de nincs mi alapján. Ennél persze sokkal bonyolultabb a történet…

 

Ockham

guillermo-de-ockham.jpgWilliam Ockham 1300 körül élt, és a világmindenség nagy kérdéseire próbált logikus válaszokat találni. Nem keltett ez akkoriban nagyobb feltűnést a filozófusok között, inkább az okozhatott gondot, amikor teológiai kérdésekre is kivetette az általa alkalmazott elveket. Miután az egyházból kiközösítették, IV Lajostól kért menedéket, továbbiakban politikáról és teológiáról írt.

 

Az elv

Két fő elvet tulajdonítanak neki, az egyik a mindenhatóság elve, a másik a gazdaságossági elv, ez utóbbi lenne a borotvához kapcsolodó.

 

De miért borotva?

"Borotvával hasítsuk ketté a szükségtelen hipotéziseket!" Állítólag így fogalmazott Ockham, mikor a gazdaságossági elvet bizonygatta. Maga az elv már létezett, Ockham csak felhasználta azt, de annyiszor és olyan sok formában, hogy idővel az ő nevéhez kötődött. A borotva, lehetne olló, vagy radír, vagy bármi ami kivonja a létezésből a szükségtelen feltételezéseket.

 

Mert mi az a gazdaságossági elv?

ockham-s-razor.gifErről bezzeg olvashatunk oldalakon át, különböző tudományos, néha egészen elvont témakörökben, és számtalan példával magyarázva, ameddig a végén a megértésből eljuthatunk, a mégsem egészen érthető, sőt igencsak ellenmondásos, aztán nagyon zavaros és egészen érthetetlen állapotig is.

Ocham borotvája, a gazdaságossági elv, a szükségtelen többlet elve, a logikai borotva, a takarékosság elve, a tömörség elve elnevezéseivel is ugyan azt a tételt fogalmazza meg:  A sokaság szükségtelenül nem tételezendő! Tehát ha egy tény, két különböző, de logikus további tényezőkre vezethető vissza, akkor azt kell választanunk, amiben kevesebb plusz feltételezés szükséges a magyarázathoz. Aki nem hiszi, járjon utána:

http://mek.oszk.hu/05200/05243/05243.htm

http://hu.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam_borotv%C3%A1ja

http://www.szabadgondolkodo.hu/szkeptikus/szotar/occam.php

http://ertem.hu/occam-borotvaja/

http://forum.szkeptikus.hu/viewtopic.php?p=39881

 

http://www.agent.ai/main.php/www.../img/main.php?folderID=166&articleID=2149&ctag=&ii

 

Érdekességek

A jó tétel minden időben, és minden helyzetben alkalmazható, így olyan témakörökben is találkozhatunk vele, amiről a 14. században még nem sokat tudhattak az emberek.

http://www.csatolna.hu/hu/erdekes/CsA/erdekes2125.htm

 

William of Ockham

vagy más írásmóddal Occam (1285?-1349) egy angol ferencesrendi barát volt, a 14. századi skolasztikus teológia és filozófia jeles képviselője. Nevéhez fűződik a híres elv, amit Occam borotvájaként említenek és alkalmaznak még ma is a különféle tudományok művelői. Nevét utca és penzió őrzi Münchenben, ahol öregkorában élt. De viseli egy programnyelv is, amelyet sokprocesszoros rendszerek párhuzamos műveleteihez fejlesztettek ki.

Éles esze úgy vágott, mint a borotva, amikor kitalálta, hogy: Non sunt multiplicanda entia praeter necessitatem. Talán jobban érthető így: Frustra fit per plura quod potest fieri per pauciora. Neeem? Akkor próbáljuk egy újabb változatban: Pluralitas non est ponenda sine necessitate. Már világos, ugye? Ha most sem, sebaj - nézzük, kik és hogyan használják, értelmezik:

  • A filozófus. Ateista válaszok a hívők tipikus kérdéseire - Occam borotvája. Ne szaporítsd szükségtelenül az entitásokat. Tehát: ha valamit meg tudsz magyarázni egy bizonyos entitás létezésének feltételezése nélkül, akkor tedd azt. Mindig a legegyszerűbb megoldást kell választani.
  • A vegyész. Sejtelem és Ockham borotvája. Hiábavaló többhöz folyamodnunk, amikor kevesebbel is megtehetjük ugyanazt.
  • A csillagász. Hale személyes nyilatkozata az UFÓkról. Ha egy jelenségre több lehetséges magyarázat létezik, mindig a legegyszerűbbet kell választani, amely az összes megfigyelt tényről számot ad.
  • A fizikus. What is Occam's razor? Keep it simple, stupid. (Ne bonyolítsd el, te hülye! ford. CsA) Az egyszerűség elve egy heurisztika, egy ökölszabály, de sokan a fizika egy axiómájának tekintik. Nem az. Egész jól működik a filozófiában és a részecskefizikában, néha a kozmológiában vagy a pszichológiában is, ahol a dolgok várakozáson felül elbonyolódhatnak. De itt már talán egy Hamlet idézet többet ér, mint Occam borotvája: "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy." (Több dolgok vannak földön és égen, Horatio, mintsem bölcselmetek álmodni képes. ford. Arany J.)
  • Az informatikus. Hogyan működik a tudomány? A tudományos problémák megoldásánál az Occam borotvája nevű elvet használják. Az elv a konkurrens elméletek közül azt fogadja el, amely kevesebb előfeltételezést igényel.
  • A mesterséges intelligencia kutató. Occam - Eine planungsbasierte Informations-Beschaffungsmaschine A gépesített cselekvéstervezés folyamatában alkalmazzák az elvet, annak érdekében, hogy a különféle információs forrásokból adatgyűjtéssel a legegyszerűbb és legolcsóbban végrehajtható tervhez jussanak. Az internetes metakeresők programjainak alapjaiban ugyancsak felbukkan az Occam elv és a belőle kifejlesztett algoritmus.
  • Az Encyclopedia Britannica. Ockham's razor. Law of economy or Law of parsimony (a takarékosság vagy zsugoriság törvénye).

OK, már érthető. Szóval Occam borotvájával le lehet nyisszantani a gondolkodásból a fölösleget, a terjengősséget. Be is fejezem.

És ismét egy félrefordítás (Leiter Jakab után), az Ockham-féle borotva, ahol az elvek márkanevekké változnak: http://leiterjakab.blog.hu/2011/08/29/az_occam_fele_borotva

 

 

Volt ilyen címmel Dr House rész és Eurékában is használták az elvet, további előfordulásai (film, sorozat, műalkotás, formáció, stb.) kerestetnek!

Film: Kapcsolat (Contact) című sci-fi.
 

 

occam.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hozzászólások

Hozzászólás megtekintése

Hozzászólások megtekintése

First time fucked right

(Trilemma3712184, 2021.08.21 18:33)

Everytime I went into the text editor, text would disappear, then reappear. I spent hours trying to connect the dots or at least see the end of the story. Eventually I gave up and just said whatever. I'm guessing that this site is a drupal install and an older version.While still with my ex wife, I was chatting it up with other degenerative perverts on a mobile sex site. I'm pretty sure the site began with the best intentions, but over the years every chat site becomes a perv site. Anyway I was talking to another dude who seemed to have the same interests. When I showed him a picture he...
https://trilemma3712184.wordpress.com/

My Thanksgiving

(gt758874873, 2021.08.21 17:29)

I've been working at a marina in the town I lived in. I also worked at the gas station my grandma owned. My family and and some family friends were all at my grandma's house. I just got my truck so I loved driving everywhere. We realized we were running out of beer and ice. The store was closed but they gave me a key to it so i could get the beer and ice. I drove up there in my truck blasting some music. I opened up and turned on the lights and went on getting what I needed. A girl walked in as I was about to turn off the lights. She was really pretty. About 5'6", thin, blonde hair that was a...
https://gt758874873.wordpress.com/

Monica and Sandi

(Dilatometer6971713, 2021.08.21 16:25)

mmmmm...." Sandi moaned her fifthorgasm of the evening.Light sparkled off the sweat that poured over hercreamy skin.Her bountiful breasts heaved in ecstasy as Monica ate out theblonde's tasty pussy.The taste of strawberries was unmistakable.(Thatwas a great idea that Sandi had with the whip cream and ripe berries.) Hernew craving for tongue was insatiable; Monica ran her tongue over theprickly surface of Sandi's shaved twat.To watch them it would bedifficult to tell that this was only Sandi's first experience in the armsof another woman.She licked up the cum dripping from...
https://dilatometer6971713.wordpress.com/

exegreeNeaniug edewd

(Manuelthava, 2021.08.21 15:44)

get credit report https://freecreditscoreses.com/# credit report

Myra's BDSM session on nov 13 2010

(Vcf1Expugn193747, 2021.08.21 15:21)

Sandra seemed more used to it because she seemed to have far less trouble with them. Our arms were bound tightly behind our backs at the elbows and wrists and clamps with little bells were clipped on our nipples. Our collars were tightened very tight, making it harder to breathe and a leash was attached to the D-ring at the front. A dildo gag completed the outfit. As on command both slave girls lowered themselves on their knees at the same time after they finished their work. A second later my Master and Sandra’s hubby walked in and grabbed our leashes. My Master tugged hard at my leash,...
https://vcf1expugn193747.wordpress.com/

Oduvan4ikshep Not

(Oduvan4ikshep, 2021.08.21 14:44)

Error 523 [url=https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003011431-Troubleshooting-Cloudflare-5XX-errors#523error]origin is unreachable[/url]

Oduvan4ikshep Out

(Oduvan4ikshep, 2021.08.21 14:42)

Error 523 [url=https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003011431-Troubleshooting-Cloudflare-5XX-errors#523error]origin is unreachable[/url]

Gabe and Fletcher chapter 2_(1)

(Protoplast67710, 2021.08.21 14:18)

Gabe was so cute when he was asleep. Fletcher pulled the covers they were sharing further down to discover that the bed was still pretty sticky, and it smelled lovely.Fletcher looked at Gabe's hot body, and put his arm to stroke his cheek. He moved his hand down his soft body, to end up by Gabe's penis. Fletcher checked to see if Gabe was still sleeping, then he stroked his penis. He could feel his own penis gaining an erection, and he smiled. He tucked himself closer to Gabe as he saw Gabe was getting an erection. He put his penis next to Gabe's and soon their boners were laying side by...
https://protoplast67710.wordpress.com/

Enough Time Now

(Indium9111713, 2021.08.21 13:14)

Another silent moment crawls by. “I’m just…” Holden begins. “I’m just trying to figure this out. Like you said, it’s complicated.” But no. It isn’t complicated. Holden knows what he needs to say. If he says it, it’ll uncomplicated things. A simple concept. But no. He can’t say it. He can’t – A vivid image suddenly pops in Holden’s head. It’s so bright and pure, Holden thinks he’ll go blind. And it’s all just a memory. Someone dims the lights and he can make out the scenery. A beach. Vacant. A beach towel has been laid out, and it’s baking in the sun because no one is there to shade it...
https://indium9111713.wordpress.com/

A night at the neighbors

(Perlustrate8920119, 2021.08.21 12:09)

On one side of our house was a single woman.She seemed middle aged and was relatively unattractive.Being married and basically more gay than bisexual, I did not pay much attention to women.I did notice that Jo, the neighbor, did have a fair amount of women coming by to visit.Many seemed to stay overnight.My suspicion was that she was a lesbian and was quite active sexually.I did notice a few men stopping by as well and most of them were good looking.They were in their mid 30's to mid 40's and all seemed to be in good shape.Noticing this, I decided it was time to get to know Jo a bit better.One...
https://perlustrate8920119.wordpress.com/

All For My Goddess

(Hek1364694, 2021.08.21 11:04)

After I finish cleaning him up, my goddess walks to me, hooking her leash back up and having me stand, saying "What a good boy you are, and for the rest of the day I will clean all your pre cum." As she bends and licks it off my cock, giving it a quick suck, I moan and she stops - saying "Oh your not going to cum again yet. Later my toy.My goddess said to me "You were so hot, my toy. I have a few surprises for you today. You have made me so hot and wet. First I am going to talk to the other goddesses, Then you and I are going to walk the trail." She goes over and talks with the 5 other...
https://hek1364694.wordpress.com/

My punjabi Girl Friend - 3

(Incandescent1622700, 2021.08.21 08:57)

The way she walked around in the office was indeed funny and people got suspicious and asked her, she told that her ankle got twisted but later she told me her pussy and ass was sore from the battering she got from me the other day.It was almost a week that I didn’t fuck her, my cock was aching to be in her pussy and my lips aching to suck her pussy and boobs. It was Monday and our bosses were in head office , so I planned to use the situation to the full.On an excuse that I was looking for a book , I called her upstairs in our library which was situated in our MD’s room, which could be...
https://incandescent1622700.wordpress.com/

THE WILLING SLAVE: A LOVE STORY

(Sumper1789926, 2021.08.21 07:52)

It was several minutes before we were able to speak.“I need another shower…and it’s… all… your… fault.”I rose from the bed, bent over to pick her up, and carried her to the shower.We kissed and kissed as the hot water ran over our bodies.I dried her, then myself, and we went back to bed.I had to laugh when I saw it.It looked like a hurricane had passed through.We worked together to make it then we climbed in naked, savoring the touch of skin on skin. As we fell into a deep sleep, the TV droning on all night.CHAPTER 4A month later not much had changed in terms of our sex life—we were...
https://sumper1789926.wordpress.com/

Accidentally Spying

(ViaM1010230, 2021.08.21 05:47)

and Mrs. Michaels moved in across the street.I was a curious kid, and watched from my bedroom window.There was a large moving truck with two big Samoans and a white man moving stuff out of it.The new neighbours had a lot of stuff.The coolest thing I saw coming out of the truck was a Star Wars desk.It was only kid sized, but what kid doesn't love Star Wars?I was getting bored and was about to turn away when I saw her:there was a girl about my age running around on the yard.She had flaming red pigtails which were streaming behind her, and was wearing a grass green dress.I was captive to her...
https://viam1010230.wordpress.com/

Sex Trafficking: Part 8: Carla and Sam’s Sunday Chores_(0)

(Vermeology3660068, 2021.08.21 04:43)

It’s kind of like learning to ride a bike as you are riding the bike. There’s a time for learning and a time for doing. I think now is the time for doing. We can learn later.”“I hope that’s a promise. That you will help me learn later.”“That’s a promise. You want to learn about something I’m interested in. And I think I’ll benefit from teaching you about it. It’ll make me organize my thoughts enough to communicate to you about it.“I’m going to wash your hair.“For the scalp, gentle massaging and running the fingers through the hair or touching the scalp with the fingernails can...
https://vermeology3660068.wordpress.com/

Dental Assistant Job Security

(BrutalGenie1529769, 2021.08.21 03:40)

Mara thought she looked cheap on her knees like that but that it suited Candice. They'd been co-workers for the past year and had become friends but neither of them had ever thought they'd end up in this situation. Sure they both had a small crush on Dr. Leo but that was harmless. It wasn't until her husband lost his job that she would have even considered something this extreme.Dr. Post could see that now she was making a video and asked, "Why are you doing this?"Candice wiped her face with the back of hand and climbed up onto the operating chair saying, "We just want to keep working...
https://brutalgenie1529769.wordpress.com/

The Millenium Bartender

(Hakosu5012889, 2021.08.21 02:36)

How did someone like him see me? No matter where I went that night there he was, staring into my eyes, I could just feel his eyes on me burning a hole through me was perhaps a better word. I went to the ladies room and looked into the mirror, my hair was perfect, my make up was perfect and my little black dress was immaculate and beautiful. I decided that I would speak to him. I stepped out of the room, and scanned the ever increasing crowd of people and I spotted him talking to a group of people, he handed them their drinks an then wandered back behind the bar. I looked to my left and found...
https://hakosu5012889.wordpress.com/

DOM SIR part 2_(1)

(paffa1462335, 2021.08.21 01:31)

i heard him get out of the shower and dry off. Then i heard him unwrapping the complimentary plastic cups and filling them with water. i knew he would want me to drink the water and my bladder was already bursting. He came back and laid down on the bed next to me. "Keep 'em shut," he said, as if he sensed i was tempted to open my eyes. I felt his fingers flicking over my nipples, first one then the other. Then his tongue. Oh how maddening that was! He flicked his tongue so lightly, but so quickly over the ends that were sticking out between the nipple clamps. This made the clamps bounce...
https://paffa1462335.wordpress.com/

CAW 22 Entry: Dreadnought

(KaboomView5838493, 2021.08.21 00:27)

In an attempt to speed things up, Robert suggested, "You should do this on stage. Imagine all the people you could educate with one performance."The thought of performing this act on stage with an audience turned Marie on greatly, something Robert had worked out previously. However, breathlessly, she said "Dougie would never allow it. I'm really going to have to talk to Aimée next time I see her." Dougie was Douglas Dawson the current Lord Chamberlain, whose job it was to censor stage productions, Aimée was his wife. The suggestion did seem to have an effect though, "In the case of a...
https://kaboomview5838493.wordpress.com/

Emily’s First Solo Holiday Part 06

(Sheld5751648, 2021.08.20 23:24)

After about 45 minutes Luke told me to go and see if the jet-ski people were there, that he wasn’t thinking of having another go on one, it was just an excuse for me to walk passed all the clothed people. I smiled and got to my feet.And wow, were there a lot of clothed people, most of them crammed into one area like sardines in a tin. I didn’t know how anyone could restrict themselves like that.I got quite a few people looking at me. I imagined that the men were looking with lust in their mind, and the women with either disgust or jealousy. I almost wanted to go up to the women with...
https://sheld5751648.wordpress.com/


« előző

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 | 61 | 62 | 63 | 64 | 65 | 66 | 67 | 68 | 69 | 70 | 71 | 72 | 73 | 74 | 75 | 76 | 77 | 78 | 79 | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | 89 | 90 | 91 | 92 | 93 | 94

Következő »