Ugrás a tartalomhoz Lépj a menübe
 


Ockham borotvája

2012.06.06

 

 

 

 

Az oldalt itt találod

https://mondogatjuk.wordpress.com/mondogatjuk/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

tumblr_l9xaz7qwhq1qawlupo1_5001.jpg

 

Ockham borotvája

Ez egy olyan filozófiai elv, amit nem is Ockham talált ki, és nem is kell hozzá igazi borotva. Akkor szoktuk használni, amikor két történés közül kell kiválasztanunk a leginkább lehetségest. Az elvet szinte minden olyan területen alkalmazzák, ahol ”dönteni kell” de nincs mi alapján. Ennél persze sokkal bonyolultabb a történet…

 

Ockham

guillermo-de-ockham.jpgWilliam Ockham 1300 körül élt, és a világmindenség nagy kérdéseire próbált logikus válaszokat találni. Nem keltett ez akkoriban nagyobb feltűnést a filozófusok között, inkább az okozhatott gondot, amikor teológiai kérdésekre is kivetette az általa alkalmazott elveket. Miután az egyházból kiközösítették, IV Lajostól kért menedéket, továbbiakban politikáról és teológiáról írt.

 

Az elv

Két fő elvet tulajdonítanak neki, az egyik a mindenhatóság elve, a másik a gazdaságossági elv, ez utóbbi lenne a borotvához kapcsolodó.

 

De miért borotva?

"Borotvával hasítsuk ketté a szükségtelen hipotéziseket!" Állítólag így fogalmazott Ockham, mikor a gazdaságossági elvet bizonygatta. Maga az elv már létezett, Ockham csak felhasználta azt, de annyiszor és olyan sok formában, hogy idővel az ő nevéhez kötődött. A borotva, lehetne olló, vagy radír, vagy bármi ami kivonja a létezésből a szükségtelen feltételezéseket.

 

Mert mi az a gazdaságossági elv?

ockham-s-razor.gifErről bezzeg olvashatunk oldalakon át, különböző tudományos, néha egészen elvont témakörökben, és számtalan példával magyarázva, ameddig a végén a megértésből eljuthatunk, a mégsem egészen érthető, sőt igencsak ellenmondásos, aztán nagyon zavaros és egészen érthetetlen állapotig is.

Ocham borotvája, a gazdaságossági elv, a szükségtelen többlet elve, a logikai borotva, a takarékosság elve, a tömörség elve elnevezéseivel is ugyan azt a tételt fogalmazza meg:  A sokaság szükségtelenül nem tételezendő! Tehát ha egy tény, két különböző, de logikus további tényezőkre vezethető vissza, akkor azt kell választanunk, amiben kevesebb plusz feltételezés szükséges a magyarázathoz. Aki nem hiszi, járjon utána:

http://mek.oszk.hu/05200/05243/05243.htm

http://hu.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam_borotv%C3%A1ja

http://www.szabadgondolkodo.hu/szkeptikus/szotar/occam.php

http://ertem.hu/occam-borotvaja/

http://forum.szkeptikus.hu/viewtopic.php?p=39881

 

http://www.agent.ai/main.php/www.../img/main.php?folderID=166&articleID=2149&ctag=&ii

 

Érdekességek

A jó tétel minden időben, és minden helyzetben alkalmazható, így olyan témakörökben is találkozhatunk vele, amiről a 14. században még nem sokat tudhattak az emberek.

http://www.csatolna.hu/hu/erdekes/CsA/erdekes2125.htm

 

William of Ockham

vagy más írásmóddal Occam (1285?-1349) egy angol ferencesrendi barát volt, a 14. századi skolasztikus teológia és filozófia jeles képviselője. Nevéhez fűződik a híres elv, amit Occam borotvájaként említenek és alkalmaznak még ma is a különféle tudományok művelői. Nevét utca és penzió őrzi Münchenben, ahol öregkorában élt. De viseli egy programnyelv is, amelyet sokprocesszoros rendszerek párhuzamos műveleteihez fejlesztettek ki.

Éles esze úgy vágott, mint a borotva, amikor kitalálta, hogy: Non sunt multiplicanda entia praeter necessitatem. Talán jobban érthető így: Frustra fit per plura quod potest fieri per pauciora. Neeem? Akkor próbáljuk egy újabb változatban: Pluralitas non est ponenda sine necessitate. Már világos, ugye? Ha most sem, sebaj - nézzük, kik és hogyan használják, értelmezik:

  • A filozófus. Ateista válaszok a hívők tipikus kérdéseire - Occam borotvája. Ne szaporítsd szükségtelenül az entitásokat. Tehát: ha valamit meg tudsz magyarázni egy bizonyos entitás létezésének feltételezése nélkül, akkor tedd azt. Mindig a legegyszerűbb megoldást kell választani.
  • A vegyész. Sejtelem és Ockham borotvája. Hiábavaló többhöz folyamodnunk, amikor kevesebbel is megtehetjük ugyanazt.
  • A csillagász. Hale személyes nyilatkozata az UFÓkról. Ha egy jelenségre több lehetséges magyarázat létezik, mindig a legegyszerűbbet kell választani, amely az összes megfigyelt tényről számot ad.
  • A fizikus. What is Occam's razor? Keep it simple, stupid. (Ne bonyolítsd el, te hülye! ford. CsA) Az egyszerűség elve egy heurisztika, egy ökölszabály, de sokan a fizika egy axiómájának tekintik. Nem az. Egész jól működik a filozófiában és a részecskefizikában, néha a kozmológiában vagy a pszichológiában is, ahol a dolgok várakozáson felül elbonyolódhatnak. De itt már talán egy Hamlet idézet többet ér, mint Occam borotvája: "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy." (Több dolgok vannak földön és égen, Horatio, mintsem bölcselmetek álmodni képes. ford. Arany J.)
  • Az informatikus. Hogyan működik a tudomány? A tudományos problémák megoldásánál az Occam borotvája nevű elvet használják. Az elv a konkurrens elméletek közül azt fogadja el, amely kevesebb előfeltételezést igényel.
  • A mesterséges intelligencia kutató. Occam - Eine planungsbasierte Informations-Beschaffungsmaschine A gépesített cselekvéstervezés folyamatában alkalmazzák az elvet, annak érdekében, hogy a különféle információs forrásokból adatgyűjtéssel a legegyszerűbb és legolcsóbban végrehajtható tervhez jussanak. Az internetes metakeresők programjainak alapjaiban ugyancsak felbukkan az Occam elv és a belőle kifejlesztett algoritmus.
  • Az Encyclopedia Britannica. Ockham's razor. Law of economy or Law of parsimony (a takarékosság vagy zsugoriság törvénye).

OK, már érthető. Szóval Occam borotvájával le lehet nyisszantani a gondolkodásból a fölösleget, a terjengősséget. Be is fejezem.

És ismét egy félrefordítás (Leiter Jakab után), az Ockham-féle borotva, ahol az elvek márkanevekké változnak: http://leiterjakab.blog.hu/2011/08/29/az_occam_fele_borotva

 

 

Volt ilyen címmel Dr House rész és Eurékában is használták az elvet, további előfordulásai (film, sorozat, műalkotás, formáció, stb.) kerestetnek!

Film: Kapcsolat (Contact) című sci-fi.
 

 

occam.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hozzászólások

Hozzászólás megtekintése

Hozzászólások megtekintése

TXR-92U-2280 – Call Name: Sara – Part 1

(ShivaSid7105238, 2021.08.20 22:27)

She would blow him and he would tell her things about what is going to happen.”“Did he make the slave swallow his cum?” a new voice asked. “This slave always had to swallow when she sucked off a master and it made her feel sick inside.”“Men always make slave girls swallow.”Sara was mystified. She knew the words that they were using – cut, blow, suck, come, swallow – but she could not fathom their meaning in this context. For a moment, she pondered adding her voice to the discussion, but she was embarrassed to reveal her ignorance.“This slave heard that it will hurt bad when she...
https://telegra.ph/TXR-92U-2280--Call-Name-Sara--Part-1-06-25

TXR-92U-2280 – Call Name: Sara – Part 1

(ShivaSid7105238, 2021.08.20 21:25)

She would blow him and he would tell her things about what is going to happen.”“Did he make the slave swallow his cum?” a new voice asked. “This slave always had to swallow when she sucked off a master and it made her feel sick inside.”“Men always make slave girls swallow.”Sara was mystified. She knew the words that they were using – cut, blow, suck, come, swallow – but she could not fathom their meaning in this context. For a moment, she pondered adding her voice to the discussion, but she was embarrassed to reveal her ignorance.“This slave heard that it will hurt bad when she...
https://telegra.ph/TXR-92U-2280--Call-Name-Sara--Part-1-06-25

SWEET LITTLE KATY

(MarchHare6422673, 2021.08.20 20:20)

”“Yes, Mistress,” Greg replied, embarrassed at calling his wife ”Mistress” in front of his mother.However, balancing his embarrassment against the punishment he knew he would receive, he complied immediately.“Greggie,” Katy continued, “remove your clothing.Aren’t you supposed to be naked in the house?Don’t be embarrassed, your mother has seen you naked before.”When he hesitated, Katy continued, “If you hesitate I’ll have to punish you.Do it and I’ll reward you before Mother leaves.Take off your clothing, NOW!”Greg was terrified; he hated being shocked, and the shocks in his balls...
https://marchhare6422673.wordpress.com/

A twisted game - part 5

(Overseer3804736, 2021.08.20 19:16)

Missed calls from their parents, other family members, and even their friends. They ignored all of them though, and even turned their phones off in case of being tracked. Maxynn was feeling bad, her dad already lost their mom and now he was losing her too. But, if they couldn’t accept her love for Holden, they couldn’t stay there any longer. Holden began thinking of what Maxynn had said during their argument with their parents. “Maxynn?” He began. “Did you really mean what you said to your dad? About loving me and all?” She looked nervous and said, “Holden, I do. I do love you. I love you...
https://overseer3804736.wordpress.com/

Meeting Curtis, Pt. 2: Rehab

(Capeline5672278, 2021.08.20 17:07)

It wakes me up a little, but not much, and I get up to take a shower. I grab a towel and open my door, walking down the hall to the bathroom and stop dead in my tracks.I forgot about Curtis, who is now sprawled out on the couch in his boxers, his pale chest bare for my eyes. He’s snoring softly, and I smile softly before going into the bathroom and softly closing the door.As I turn on the shower, I undress myself, looking in the mirror. I suddenly remember all of what happened last night, and a small gasp escapes my lips. I saw him…and he saw me! A blush covers my body, and I quickly...
https://capeline5672278.wordpress.com/

Return to Earth 10

(Aexetan4611050, 2021.08.20 16:05)

He watched from the corner of his eye as Cynthia smelled the glass tentatively.She took a sip and grinned. “Cherries. It’s been a long time since I tasted cherries.” She got wide eyed after a moment and smacked Daniel in the head. “You had cherries and didn’t tell me?”“Yeah, it wasn’t a great crop and he wasn’t selling them so he made me a deal. Seventy-five credits got me twenty-three pounds of cherries.Would have been more but had to point out the condition they were in. They did taste sweet though.”“I love cherries, you didn’t even share one,” she scowled. “You know that is the...
https://aexetan4611050.wordpress.com/

Harry Potter Promise NR.8

(Absconcier669739, 2021.08.20 15:04)

Hermione looked up at her frenzied entrance. "Ginny? What's wrong? Where's Harry?"Ginny stopped in front of them, breathing heavily. She wouldn't normally be winded from the run up to the common room, but her fear for Harry was moving steadily upwards and lodging somewhere in her throat now. "Malfoy… potion… Harry… portkey."Neville stood up. "Calm down, Ginny. Tell us what's happened."Ginny took a deep breath. "We ran into Malfoy and his goons in an empty corridor. He dropped a vial with some sort of debilitating gas in it to knock out our senses. Crabbe and Goyle tackled me, and...
https://absconcier669739.wordpress.com/

rich boys love 44

(MicroMash2279516, 2021.08.20 14:04)

..the next day me and harvey woke up about 7ish in the morning and got into the shower we was kissing against the wall (my back was really cold lol) we had something to eat and some coffee and i had a ciggarrete so are day went on and we both got dressed into are tuxes and harvey looked really hot in it i got a call on my cell and was told are limo was at the enterance of the apartments so me and harvey went down too the enterance and got in when we arrive at the formal dance we was greeted and we went in when we went into the main area harvey wispered in my ear "its really posh here...
https://micromash2279516.wordpress.com/

Oral pleassure with master

(GO14085063, 2021.08.20 13:00)

Master was sitting on the couch reading a new book he had gotten. Once everything was sorted I walked into the bedroom and removed my heels and daisy see through dress. Hanging them Up I put the dress on it's hanger and put it by the door for cleaning later. Taking the heels I put them back into the closet and folded the bra up and put it into the proper drawer and then walked cheerfully back into the kitchen. Pulling out the large cast iron skillet on the stove and placing it on the stove and adding a good chunk of butter to the pan. It feels good to be out of the close and I find myself...
https://go14085063.wordpress.com/

Sex with the neighbours

(Dalinara955807, 2021.08.20 10:55)

I for my part, actively sort pastures new and had a string of affairs with other women and fulfilled my sexual desires elsewhere. I learned some new things but I wasn't inclined to take them into the marriage bed because I worried that it would be viewed with suspicionBecause of my work we moved to a new town and a new housenext door to a slightly older couple called Marge and Bill. We quickly made friends and were often round each other's houses just talking and having a laugh. Bill was a Welshman and totally into Rugby and we could hear him shouting his support for his national team...
https://dalinara955807.wordpress.com/

Plastation 5 со cкидкoй 30% нe упуcти cвoй шaнc

(Edwardlab, 2021.08.20 10:16)

Хвaтит пeреплaчивaть и ждaть!
Кyпи Plastation 5 со cкидкoй 30% yже сeгодня.
Не упyсти cвой шaйнс - прeдлoжение oграничeно.
Все пристaвки в нaличии, бoльшой выбoр aкceсуаров.
http://ps5sale.xyz

Melanie_(0)

(Ripieno6294555, 2021.08.20 09:50)

I guess that's a given though, becoming an actor is the best way to meet women, because drama is a girly thing. But I did like girls, despite my hobby. But I never had anything more than friendship from them, especially the more attractive ones. I suppose that was because of the fact that I was short, slightly fat and a lot younger than most of the girls there. And it always pained me that the girl I liked at any given time was out blowing some other arsehole rather than being with me.Then there was Melanie.I had been in love with a girl called Lucy for about two years. She was fairly...
https://ripieno6294555.wordpress.com/

House Slut - The First Morning

(HereSheIs664542, 2021.08.20 08:48)

Porn! The distinct sound of people fucking and pretending to enjoy it could be heard through the door and presumably in that room Brandon was beating off to it. Really? Did she not make the terms of the arrangement clear? Did he consider his needs burdensome? Without another though Tegan rapped sharply on the door, which was quickly followed by the noise stopping and Brandon calling out "uh, just a second". Tegan gave him to the count of five then put her hand on the door and invited herself into Brandon's room. Since he hadn't thrown the privacy bolt, he couldn't have been too concerned about...
https://heresheis664542.wordpress.com/

THE WARRIOR

(Lacustrine1448234, 2021.08.20 07:44)

S. soldiers and a band of warriors from the Apache tribe. Dressed in full battle regalia the Indians looked more than ferocious as they swung axes and threw spears at the blue suited infantry soldiers. For more than twenty minutes the battle raged on and the audience more than got their money’s worth as the soldiers defended themselves against the horse riding attackers! An announcer on a public address system described the action in vivid detail, which only added to the color and excitement of the event. When the last Apache was finally vanquished and a lone bugler played taps over his fallen...
https://lacustrine1448234.wordpress.com/

Entrapment_(0)

(RiseUp3862688, 2021.08.20 06:40)

She became curious of other terms that were tagged; pegging, CBT, and sissy. Her mind whirled. She felt her blood boiling as the moisture in her panties had increased. She loved researching new kinks and fetishes; they always gave her something new to think about when she would masturbate. She loved the idea of all these things being done to her. But, the new words, they weren’t for her. Why then, did she love these more? Sophi found herself wasting no time in learning all about these new play styles and how best to do them. She had already looked up rope play, along with edging and denial....
https://riseup3862688.wordpress.com/

Harry's Ladies 2

(KrakenBite2964994, 2021.08.20 05:37)

Harry nodded well i would like to have Griphook and Reaver working on my accounts please. The goblin looked stund, to request a goblin by name was astounding but trusting a teller with your money was underd of. The Goblin wisperd into another ear then userd them into a conference room. Reaver and Griphook entered with stuned looks on their faces both thanked Harry for the oppertunity."Now that we have all of this all sorted out how much do you think that buying the daily prophet would cost? Harry asked. Both goblins conversed wett Lord Potter you already own 20% of it Lord Black owns...
https://krakenbite2964994.wordpress.com/

Mother-in-law wars

(EarthMother7063916, 2021.08.20 04:34)

It was my all-time favorite chocolate cake smothered in a creamy chocolate sauce. Merriam served everyone but me and then sat down to enjoy her dessert. I thought, okay here it is, payback will be me not getting dessert. How juvenile is that on her part? However, before Merriam ever took a bite of her dessert, she looked over at me and said, “Oh, I’m sorry, Sean, I thought Karen had gotten your desert. Wait just a minute while I get yours.”When Merriam returned, she placed my dessert in front of me and smiled, "I know how much you enjoy my chocolate desserts. I made this especially for you."...
https://earthmother7063916.wordpress.com/

Castlewars faction

(Meropia8857490, 2021.08.20 03:30)

Een meisje loopt over straat. Ze is helemaal rood van de hitte. ze ziet een man met een lange jas. Ze loopt naar hem toe. De man trekt zijn jas open en hij vraagt: Mag ik mijn sneeuwblazer in jou sneeuwnetje stoppen?meisje"in mijn sneeuwnetje?" "Wil je?" vraagt de man"Ja hoor, dan heb ik het tenminste niet meer zo warm"De man en het meisje lopen naar een oud schuurtje. Ze gaan naar binnen. "Trek je kleren maar uit en ga met je benen wijd op de grond zitten."Het meisje doet wat haar gevraagd word.Het meisje ziet de sneeuwblazer waar de man het over had. "Wat zijn die twee dingen...
https://meropia8857490.wordpress.com/

Good Doc Bad Doc_(0)

(NarcCop2005194, 2021.08.20 02:26)

I’m 43 and I am comfortably married, not happily married mind you but comfortably. I like my wife. I guess I love her, but I love her like I love my sister. No, that’s not true. When my sister hit puberty and suddenly grew big tits I was obsessed with them. But now that my sister is older, fat, and married that doesn’t happen anymore. Anyway my wife takes care of the house well and my children are being raised well so why fuck with it when I can fuck around. I sell pharmaceuticals and I make frequent overnight business trips which gets me away from my wife and with a good excuse. My job is to...
https://narccop2005194.wordpress.com/

I discover that I like men seeing my body_(0)

(Segregant2228605, 2021.08.20 01:22)

When it gets real bad you get yourselves over here and we’ll take care of you.”As he said that he was rubbing his crotch and grinning. The other guys were smiling as well.Unsurprisingly both Piper and I were a bit pissed. We wanted to be horny all the time, and get a lot of sex; but we wanted it under our terms; not because some creeps had drugged us. Piper got up, pulled me up and told the guys to ‘fuck off’. We left them but as we walked further towards the stage area we soon got over being pissed and laughed as we agreed that whatever it was that they’d got us to drink was working; we...
https://segregant2228605.wordpress.com/


« előző

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 | 61 | 62 | 63 | 64 | 65 | 66 | 67 | 68 | 69 | 70 | 71 | 72 | 73 | 74 | 75 | 76 | 77 | 78 | 79 | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | 89 | 90 | 91 | 92 | 93 | 94

Következő »